A Quiet Place has a high concept, basic drama, and a contrived plot. Character choices are forced and internal conflicts are simplistic. Thus, emotional connection is vague, with unexplored themes and unearned arcs. Meanwhile, the monster rules are inconsistent, turning an intriguing premise into just another collection of genre tropes. Despite all the emphasis put on its gimmick, this is functionally the same as any other formulaic creature feature. Plus, there's blunt dialogue, mediocre exposition, repetition, and no resolution. Although intense and believable, the acting can feel one-note. Overall, A Quiet Place's lacking depth makes it adequate but wasted potential.
Technically, A Quiet Place is unelevated. Its tone comes across as more melodramatic than tense. The imagery uses lighting, angles, and framing to look cinematic yet mostly meaningless. Pacing shifts, cross cuts, and a short runtime make for sufficient editing. The music borders on generic and overdone. Despite some detail in the world-building, the production design is fairly derivative with its monsters. The cast has moderate fame and solid fit. Its effects add proficient CGI. Finally, the sound design is fundamental to the plot, utilizing risers, genre elements, muffling, smash cuts, and split cuts. Consequently, A Quiet Place is generally competent but rarely masterful.
Writing: 5/10
Direction: 6/10
Cinematography: 7/10
Acting: 8/10
Editing: 7/10
Sound: 10/10
Score/Soundtrack: 6/10
Production Design: 7/10
Casting: 7/10
Effects: 7/10
Overall Score: 7.0/10
Comentários