The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey is overdone. Its script adds superfluous material to a classic story. These unrelated scenes are the weakest parts and they also undermine The Hobbit's core intimacy. There are extended periods where Bilbo isn't present and the primary plot isn't advanced. This is exacerbated by the original book being cut into three films that require separate conclusions, resulting in contrived and disjointed story beats. There's flat characterization, little setup/payoff, no tension, minimal themes, forced arcs, and a muddled narrative. An Unexpected Journey has value buried within, but its emotional connection is confused by bloated writing.
Technically, An Unexpected Journey is elaborate but conflicted. It tonally clashes, turning a simple quest into an epic LOTR prequel. Its exhausting editing fumbles the pacing and momentum. Conversely, visuals are pretty, acting is endearing, effects are significant (despite being overly CGI and inconsistent), and the cast is key. Also, the music misuses nostalgic songs, yet is grand and fitting. The sound uses echoes, emphasis, and distortions to heighten the complex fantasy designs. Plus, the production design effectively recaptures the unique world-building. Thus, An Unexpected Journey's technicals buoy its flawed drama. Ultimately, it's a letdown but has merit.
Writing: 5/10
Direction: 6/10
Cinematography: 8/10
Acting: 8/10
Editing: 6/10
Sound: 9/10
Score/Soundtrack: 8/10
Production Design: 9/10
Casting: 8/10
Effects: 8/10
Overall Score: 7.5/10
Comments