Prometheus is a respectable mess. It has a contrived plot, abrupt drama, and inconsequential sub-threads. Yet, the writing attempts philosophical themes like existentialism, humanity, faith, sacrifice, and nihilism. It's just that they don't derive any concrete conclusions, which further weakens the payoff. There's clunky exposition, thin resolution, inconsistent motivations, nonsensical logistics, and pointless twists. The dialogue is often unnatural. Characters are superfluous, simplistic, and erratic. Its acting combats these faults, elevating the personality, intensity, layers, and vulnerability of the script. Thus, Prometheus buries musing nuggets within a jumbled story.
Technically, Prometheus is more adept. Although muddled, its direction builds a pensive mood. The imagery conveys grandeur with framing and lighting. Despite suspenseful sequences, its editing loses momentum through its convoluted structure. Atmosphere, genre elements, stings, and subjectivity make a rich soundscape. Its orchestral music creates wonder and a memorable motif. The detailed production design adds colors, diverse aesthetics, and perhaps too sterile sci-fi. Its cast has fame, but fits are spotty and the leads are replaceable. While varied and well-integrated, some effects are less convincing. Ultimately, Prometheus mitigates fundamental flaws with sizable craft.
Writing: 4/10
Direction: 6/10
Cinematography: 8/10
Acting: 7/10
Editing: 6/10
Sound: 8/10
Score/Soundtrack: 7/10
Production Design: 8/10
Casting: 7/10
Effects: 8/10
Overall Score: 6.9/10
Commentaires