Sonic the Hedgehog is generic. The script haphazardly tosses Sonic's eccentric reality into a trite family film, without harmonizing the genres. Aimlessly alternating between Sonic action and stale buddy adventures, Sonic the Hedgehog provides nothing new or genuine. In fact, the story is so lifeless, Marsden visibly struggles through earlier scenes. His chemistry with Schwartz eventually develops, but even when the plot moves, it's emotionally empty. Ultimately, Sonic the Hedgehog is an overextended commercial. Carrey and Schwartz are playful, but this story is a franchise leech. Because there's no insight, drama, surprise, or creativity, Sonic the Hedgehog is bland.
Meanwhile, Sonic the Hedgehog's filmmaking is equally forgettable. The sound is solid (with whizzing and mechanics) and the cast is fairly recognizable. There's a crafty shot or two, a fun Carrey dance number, decent CGI (but poor green screening), and an efficient runtime. Yet, those are outliers. The cinematography, music, effects, and editing are largely unimpressive. Generally, the experience is presented plainly, without craft. Plus, the production design clashes and possesses excessive product placements. Furthermore, the mood is flat, never daring to get uncomfortable. Overall, Sonic the Hedgehog isn't too painful, but it's completely dull and predictable.
Writing: 2/10
Direction: 3/10
Cinematography: 5/10
Acting: 6/10
Editing: 5/10
Sound: 6/10
Score/Soundtrack: 5/10
Production Design: 3/10
Casting: 6/10
Effects: 5/10
Overall Score: 4.6/10
Comments